Discrimination In Disability Benefits
EDM number 953 in 2003-04, proposed by Roger Berry on 31/03/2004.
That this House believes that it is injust and discriminatory to deny people who become disabled from the age of 65 the opportunity to claim disability living allowance; further believes that the alternative benefit offered to older disabled people, attendance allowance, is inadequate because it does not contain a mobility component, is not available to those with lower-level needs and requires a claimant to wait three months longer before making a claim; notes further that attendance allowance does not passport its recipients to the Motability scheme, or exemption from vehicle exise duty; further believes that this differentiation between older and younger disabled people is based on an outmoded and unfounded conception of older people as inactive and non-contributing members of society; and therefore urges the Government to support the aims of the Mobilise campaign, to end age discrimination in disability benefit and make a genuine commitment to active ageing and the full participatory citizenship of older people.
This motion has been signed by a total of 244 MPs, 1 of these signatures have been withdrawn.
MP | Date | Constituency | Party | Type |
Roger Berry | 31/03/2004 | Kingswood | Labour | Proposed |
Paul Burstow | 31/03/2004 | Sutton & Cheam | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Ronnie Campbell | 31/03/2004 | Blyth Valley | Labour | Signed |
Peter Bottomley | 31/03/2004 | Worthing West | Conservative | Signed |
Simon Thomas | 31/03/2004 | Ceredigion | Plaid Cymru | Signed |
Martin Smyth | 01/04/2004 | Belfast South | UUP | Signed |
Bob Spink | 01/04/2004 | Castle Point | Conservative | Signed |
Paul Holmes | 01/04/2004 | Chesterfield | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Simon Hughes | 01/04/2004 | North Southwark & Bermondsey | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Eric Illsley | 01/04/2004 | Barnsley Central | Labour | Signed |
Lynne Jones | 01/04/2004 | Birmingham, Selly Oak | Labour | Signed |
Kevin McNamara | 01/04/2004 | Kingston upon Hull North | Labour | Signed |
Gregory Campbell | 01/04/2004 | East Londonderry | DUP | Signed |
Sue Doughty | 01/04/2004 | Guildford | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Andrew George | 01/04/2004 | St Ives | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Win Griffiths | 01/04/2004 | Bridgend | Labour | Signed |
Harry Barnes | 01/04/2004 | North East Derbyshire | Labour | Signed |
Desmond Turner | 01/04/2004 | Brighton, Kemptown | Labour | Signed |
Paul Tyler | 01/04/2004 | North Cornwall | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Michael Weir | 01/04/2004 | Angus | Scottish National Party | Signed |
Adam Price | 19/04/2004 | Carmarthen East & Dinefwr | Plaid Cymru | Signed |
Lindsay Hoyle | 19/04/2004 | Chorley | Labour | Signed |
Chris McCafferty | 19/04/2004 | Calder Valley | Labour | Signed |
Martin Caton | 19/04/2004 | Gower | Labour | Signed |
Jeremy Corbyn | 19/04/2004 | Islington North | Labour | Signed |
Annabelle Ewing | 19/04/2004 | Perth | Scottish National Party | Signed |
Robert Wareing | 19/04/2004 | Liverpool, West Derby | Labour | Signed |
Betty Williams | 19/04/2004 | Conwy | Labour | Signed |
Phil Sawford | 20/04/2004 | Kettering | Labour | Signed |
Paul Keetch | 20/04/2004 | Hereford | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Alan Meale | 20/04/2004 | Mansfield | Labour | Signed |
Tom Brake | 20/04/2004 | Carshalton & Wallington | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Colin Burgon | 20/04/2004 | Elmet | Labour | Signed |
Ann Cryer | 20/04/2004 | Keighley | Labour | Signed |
Jim Dobbin | 20/04/2004 | Heywood & Middleton | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Huw Edwards | 20/04/2004 | Monmouth | Labour | Signed |
Vera Baird | 20/04/2004 | Redcar | Labour | Signed |
Roy Beggs | 20/04/2004 | East Antrim | UUP | Signed |
Paul Stinchcombe | 20/04/2004 | Wellingborough | Labour | Signed |
Rudi Vis | 20/04/2004 | Finchley & Golders Green | Labour | Signed |
Hywel Williams | 20/04/2004 | Caernarfon | Plaid Cymru | Signed |
Gwyn Prosser | 21/04/2004 | Dover | Labour | Signed |
Ernie Ross | 21/04/2004 | Dundee West | Labour | Signed |
Nigel Jones | 21/04/2004 | Cheltenham | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Elfyn Llwyd | 21/04/2004 | Meirionnydd Nant Conwy | Plaid Cymru | Signed |
John McDonnell | 21/04/2004 | Hayes & Harlington | Labour | Signed |
Denis Murphy | 21/04/2004 | Wansbeck | Labour | Signed |
Albert Owen | 21/04/2004 | Ynys M | Labour | Signed |
Annette Brooke | 21/04/2004 | Mid Dorset & North Poole | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Richard Burden | 21/04/2004 | Birmingham, Northfield | Labour | Signed |
David Drew | 21/04/2004 | Stroud | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Hywel Francis | 21/04/2004 | Aberavon | Labour | Signed |
Neil Gerrard | 21/04/2004 | Walthamstow | Labour | Signed |
Tony Baldry | 21/04/2004 | Banbury | Conservative | Signed |
Alan Simpson | 22/04/2004 | Nottingham South | Labour | Signed |
David Heath | 22/04/2004 | Somerton & Frome | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Lady Hermon | 22/04/2004 | North Down | UUP | Signed |
Piara S Khabra | 22/04/2004 | Ealing, Southall | Labour | Signed |
David Kidney | 22/04/2004 | Stafford | Labour | Signed |
Harry Cohen | 22/04/2004 | Leyton & Wanstead | Labour | Signed |
Janet Dean | 22/04/2004 | Burton | Labour | Signed |
David Hamilton | 22/04/2004 | Midlothian | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Stunell | 22/04/2004 | Hazel Grove | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Desmond Swayne | 26/04/2004 | New Forest West | Conservative | Signed |
Nigel Dodds | 27/04/2004 | Belfast North | DUP | Signed |
Paul Marsden | 28/04/2004 | Shrewsbury & Atcham | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Alan Hurst | 30/04/2004 | Braintree | Labour | Signed |
Bob Russell | 04/05/2004 | Colchester | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Clive Efford | 04/05/2004 | Eltham | Labour | Signed |
David Amess | 04/05/2004 | Southend West | Conservative | Signed |
John Barrett | 04/05/2004 | Edinburgh West | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Nicholas Winterton | 04/05/2004 | Macclesfield | Conservative | Signed |
Bill Etherington | 05/05/2004 | Sunderland North | Labour | Signed |
Linda Perham | 06/05/2004 | Ilford North | Labour | Signed |
Keith Bradley | 06/05/2004 | Manchester, Withington | Labour | Signed |
Brian White | 06/05/2004 | North East Milton Keynes | Labour | Signed |
Virginia Bottomley | 10/05/2004 | South West Surrey | Conservative | Signed |
Richard Taylor | 10/05/2004 | Wyre Forest | Independent | Signed |
Doug Henderson | 11/05/2004 | Newcastle upon Tyne North | Labour | Signed |
Sandra Osborne | 11/05/2004 | Ayr | Labour | Signed |
John Greenway | 12/05/2004 | Ryedale | Conservative | Signed |
Paul Flynn | 13/05/2004 | Newport West | Labour | Signed |
Alan Beith | 13/05/2004 | Berwick-upon-Tweed | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Graham Stringer | 17/05/2004 | Manchester, Blackley | Labour | Signed |
Derek Wyatt | 17/05/2004 | Sittingbourne & Sheppey | Labour | Signed |
John Randall | 18/05/2004 | Uxbridge | Conservative | Signed |
Kate Hoey | 18/05/2004 | Vauxhall | Labour | Signed |
Colin Breed | 18/05/2004 | South East Cornwall | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Tony Colman | 19/05/2004 | Putney | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Selous | 20/05/2004 | South West Bedfordshire | Conservative | Signed |
John Smith | 20/05/2004 | Vale of Glamorgan | Labour | Signed |
Edward Davey | 20/05/2004 | Kingston & Surbiton | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Hilton Dawson | 20/05/2004 | Lancaster & Wyre | Labour | Signed |
John Butterfill | 21/05/2004 | Bournemouth West | Conservative | Signed |
Stephen Dorrell | 21/05/2004 | Charnwood | Conservative | Signed |
Jenny Tonge | 21/05/2004 | Richmond Park | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Robert Walter | 21/05/2004 | North Dorset | Conservative | Signed |
Iain Coleman | 24/05/2004 | Hammersmith & Fulham | Labour | Signed |
John Pugh | 25/05/2004 | Southport | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Tony Clarke | 25/05/2004 | Northampton South | Labour | Signed |
Richard Shepherd | 26/05/2004 | Aldridge-Brownhills | Conservative | Signed |
Julie Morgan | 27/05/2004 | Cardiff North | Labour | Signed |
Christine Russell | 27/05/2004 | Chester, City of | Labour | Signed |
Helen Jackson | 27/05/2004 | Sheffield, Hillsborough | Labour | Signed |
John Mann | 27/05/2004 | Bassetlaw | Labour | Signed |
Adrian Sanders | 07/06/2004 | Torbay | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Malcolm Savidge | 07/06/2004 | Aberdeen North | Labour | Signed |
Brian Sedgemore | 07/06/2004 | Hackney South & Shoreditch | Labour | Signed |
Barry Sheerman | 07/06/2004 | Huddersfield | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Robert Smith | 07/06/2004 | West Aberdeenshire & Kincardine | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
David Heyes | 07/06/2004 | Ashton-under-Lyne | Labour | Signed |
Joan Humble | 07/06/2004 | Blackpool North & Fleetwood | Labour | Signed |
Brian Iddon | 07/06/2004 | Bolton South East | Labour | Signed |
Diana Organ | 07/06/2004 | Forest of Dean | Labour | Signed |
Anne Campbell | 07/06/2004 | Cambridge | Labour | Signed |
Jim Cunningham | 07/06/2004 | Coventry South | Labour | Signed |
Wayne David | 07/06/2004 | Caerphilly | Labour | Signed |
Sarah Teather | 07/06/2004 | Brent East | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
John Wilkinson | 07/06/2004 | Ruislip - Northwood | Conservative | Signed |
Michael Clapham | 08/06/2004 | Barnsley West & Penistone | Labour | Signed |
Glenda Jackson | 09/06/2004 | Hampstead & Highgate | Labour | Signed |
Doug Naysmith | 09/06/2004 | Bristol North West | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Mark Oaten | 09/06/2004 | Winchester | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Kevin Brennan | 09/06/2004 | Cardiff West | Labour | Signed |
Alistair Carmichael | 09/06/2004 | Orkney & Shetland | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Tom Cox | 09/06/2004 | Tooting | Labour | Signed |
Richard Allan | 09/06/2004 | Sheffield, Hallam | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Henry Bellingham | 09/06/2004 | North West Norfolk | Conservative | Signed |
David Taylor | 09/06/2004 | North West Leicestershire | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Peter Robinson | 10/06/2004 | Belfast East | DUP | Signed |
Parmjit Dhanda | 14/06/2004 | Gloucester | Labour | Signed |
Eddie McGrady | 14/06/2004 | South Down | Social Democratic and Labour Party | Signed |
Brian Cotter | 14/06/2004 | Weston-Super-Mare | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Frank Roy | 15/06/2004 | Motherwell & Wishaw | Labour | Signed |
David Burnside | 15/06/2004 | South Antrim | UUP | Signed |
Brian H Donohoe | 15/06/2004 | Cunninghame South | Labour | Signed |
John Taylor | 15/06/2004 | Solihull | Conservative | Signed |
Gillian Shephard | 16/06/2004 | South West Norfolk | Conservative | Signed |
Helen Clark | 16/06/2004 | Peterborough | Labour | Signed |
Peter Ainsworth | 16/06/2004 | East Surrey | Conservative | Signed |
Tony Banks | 16/06/2004 | West Ham | Labour | Signed |
Alan Reid | 18/06/2004 | Argyll & Bute | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Geraldine Smith | 18/06/2004 | Morecambe & Lunesdale | Labour | Signed |
Martyn Jones | 18/06/2004 | Clwyd South | Labour | Signed |
Edward O'Hara | 18/06/2004 | Knowsley South | Labour | Signed |
Jim Cousins | 18/06/2004 | Newcastle upon Tyne Central | Labour | Signed |
Lembit | 21/06/2004 | Montgomeryshire | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Debra Shipley | 22/06/2004 | Stourbridge | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Hunter | 22/06/2004 | Basingstoke | Independent Conservative | Signed |
Peter Bradley | 22/06/2004 | Wrekin, The | Labour | Signed |
Harold Best | 22/06/2004 | Leeds North West | Labour | Signed |
Valerie Davey | 23/06/2004 | Bristol West | Labour | Signed |
Teddy Taylor | 23/06/2004 | Rochford & Southend East | Conservative | Signed |
Jonathan R Shaw | 24/06/2004 | Chatham & Aylesford | Labour | Signed |
Joan Walley | 24/06/2004 | Stoke-on-Trent North | Labour | Signed |
Jimmy Hood | 28/06/2004 | Clydesdale | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Dismore | 28/06/2004 | Hendon | Labour | Signed |
John Burnett | 29/06/2004 | Torridge & West Devon | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Chris Mole | 30/06/2004 | Ipswich | Labour | Signed |
Geoffrey Robinson | 01/07/2004 | Coventry North West | Labour | Signed |
Don Foster | 06/07/2004 | Bath | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Dennis Turner | 06/07/2004 | Wolverhampton South East | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Bill Olner | 07/07/2004 | Nuneaton | Labour | Signed |
Paul Farrelly | 12/07/2004 | Newcastle-under-Lyme | Labour | Signed |
Roger Godsiff | 12/07/2004 | Birmingham, Sparkbrook & Small Heath | Labour | Signed |
Llew Smith | 13/07/2004 | Blaenau Gwent | Labour | Signed |
Alex Salmond | 15/07/2004 | Banff & Buchan | Scottish National Party | Signed |
Ann Winterton | 15/07/2004 | Congleton | Conservative | Signed |
Pete Wishart | 15/07/2004 | North Tayside | Scottish National Party | Signed |
Andy King | 16/07/2004 | Rugby & Kenilworth | Labour | Signed |
Gavin Strang | 16/07/2004 | Edinburgh East & Musselburgh | Labour | Signed |
Marion Roe | 19/07/2004 | Broxbourne | Conservative | Signed |
Mark Lazarowicz | 19/07/2004 | Edinburgh North & Leith | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Tony Lloyd | 19/07/2004 | Manchester Central | Labour | Signed |
Sydney Chapman | 19/07/2004 | Chipping Barnet | Conservative | Signed |
Roger Williams | 19/07/2004 | Brecon & Radnorshire | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Syd Rapson | 20/07/2004 | Portsmouth North | Labour | Signed |
Marsha Singh | 20/07/2004 | Bradford West | Labour | Signed |
Jeffrey M Donaldson | 20/07/2004 | Lagan Valley | DUP | Signed |
David Atkinson | 20/07/2004 | Bournemouth East | Conservative | Signed |
Tony Worthington | 20/07/2004 | Clydebank & Milngavie | Labour | Signed |
John Robertson | 21/07/2004 | Glasgow, Anniesland | Labour | Signed |
Mark Hendrick | 21/07/2004 | Preston | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Ian Lucas | 21/07/2004 | Wrexham | Labour | Signed |
Colin Challen | 21/07/2004 | Morley & Rothwell | Labour | Signed |
Ross Cranston | 21/07/2004 | Dudley North | Labour | Signed |
John Cummings | 21/07/2004 | Easington | Labour | Signed |
Barbara Follett | 21/07/2004 | Stevenage | Labour | Signed |
John Battle | 21/07/2004 | Leeds West | Labour | Signed |
John Thurso | 21/07/2004 | Caithness, Sutherland & Easter Ross | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
David Winnick | 21/07/2004 | Walsall North | Labour | Signed |
John MacDougall | 22/07/2004 | Central Fife | Labour | Signed |
Alice Mahon | 22/07/2004 | Halifax | Labour | Signed |
Vincent Cable | 22/07/2004 | Twickenham | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Sandra Gidley | 22/07/2004 | Romsey | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Stephen Hepburn | 07/09/2004 | Jarrow | Labour | Signed |
George Howarth | 07/09/2004 | Knowsley North & Sefton East | Labour | Signed |
Robert Jackson | 07/09/2004 | Wantage | Conservative | Signed |
Brian Jenkins | 07/09/2004 | Tamworth | Labour | Signed |
Jon Owen Jones | 07/09/2004 | Cardiff Central | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Michael Mates | 07/09/2004 | East Hampshire | Conservative | Signed |
Austin Mitchell | 07/09/2004 | Great Grimsby | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Murrison | 07/09/2004 | Westbury | Conservative | Signed |
Patsy Calton | 07/09/2004 | Cheadle | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
David Chidgey | 07/09/2004 | Eastleigh | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Michael Connarty | 07/09/2004 | Falkirk East | Labour | Signed |
Claire Curtis-Thomas | 07/09/2004 | Crosby | Labour | Signed |
Matthew Green | 07/09/2004 | Ludlow | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Candy Atherton | 07/09/2004 | Falmouth & Camborne | Labour | Signed |
John Austin | 07/09/2004 | Erith & Thamesmead | Labour | Signed |
Richard Younger-Ross | 07/09/2004 | Teignbridge | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Tony Wright | 08/09/2004 | Cannock Chase | Labour | Signed |
Michael Spicer | 09/09/2004 | West Worcestershire | Conservative | Signed |
Jim Dowd | 09/09/2004 | Lewisham West | Labour | Signed |
Frank Dobson | 13/09/2004 | Holborn & St Pancras | Labour | Signed |
Terry Lewis | 14/09/2004 | Worsley | Labour | Signed |
David Chaytor | 15/09/2004 | Bury North | Labour | Signed |
Joyce Quin | 16/09/2004 | Gateshead East & Washington West | Labour | Signed |
Phil Willis | 16/09/2004 | Harrogate & Knaresborough | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Anthony D Wright | 16/09/2004 | Great Yarmouth | Labour | Signed |
James Plaskitt | 11/10/2004 | Warwick & Leamington | Labour | Signed |
Iris Robinson | 11/10/2004 | Strangford | DUP | Signed |
Seamus Mallon | 11/10/2004 | Newry & Armagh | Social Democratic and Labour Party | Signed |
Robert Marshall-Andrews | 11/10/2004 | Medway | Labour | Signed |
Jeff Ennis | 11/10/2004 | Barnsley East & Mexborough | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Bennett | 11/10/2004 | Denton & Reddish | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Rosindell | 12/10/2004 | Romford | Conservative | Signed |
Chris Smith | 12/10/2004 | Islington South & Finsbury | Labour | Signed |
Jon Trickett | 12/10/2004 | Hemsworth | Labour | Signed |
David Trimble | 12/10/2004 | Upper Bann | UUP | Signed |
Sally Keeble | 13/10/2004 | Northampton North | Labour | Signed |
Tom Clarke | 13/10/2004 | Coatbridge & Chryston | Labour | Signed |
Martin O'Neill | 14/10/2004 | Ochil | Labour | Signed |
John McWilliam | 21/10/2004 | Blaydon | Labour | Signed |
Alan Keen | 28/10/2004 | Feltham & Heston | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Michael Meacher | 02/11/2004 | Oldham West & Royton | Labour | Signed |
Kevin Barron | 02/11/2004 | Rother Valley | Labour | Signed |
Bob Blizzard | 02/11/2004 | Waveney | Labour | Signed |
Evan Harris | 03/11/2004 | Oxford West & Abingdon | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Norman Lamb | 08/11/2004 | North Norfolk | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
George Galloway | 08/11/2004 | Glasgow, Kelvin | Independent | Signed |
Denzil Davies | 11/11/2004 | Llanelli | Labour | Signed |
Joan Ruddock | 15/11/2004 | Lewisham, Deptford | Labour | Signed |
Terry Davis | Unknown | | | Withdrawn |
Download raw data as
csv or
xml.