Treatment Of Trainee Doctors From Commonwealth And Former Commonwealth Countries
EDM number 1989 in 2005-06, proposed by Austin Mitchell on 19/04/2006.
That this House expresses its concern at the sudden and peremptory way the Home Office has rushed through without adequate debate inside Parliament or discussion outside it and with only perfunctory consultation with the British Medical Association, associations representing immigrant doctors and a health service heavily dependent on foreign doctors, changes in the immigration rules which will exclude non-EU trainee doctors from shortlists for jobs unless no EU or EEA applicants are available, impose a burden of costs, disruption and uncertainty on hospitals dependent on foreign house officers, as well as on the careers and prospects of foreign doctors training in the UK or hoping to come from India or Pakistan to make a career in the UK, and make nationality a more important qualification for medical and dental appointments than excellence, quality or language skills; suggests that to treat doctors from India, Pakistan and other Commonwealth countries in this fashion is insulting after their great contribution to the National Health Service; and, recognising that these sudden regulations have produced a state of alarm and fear among trainees from overseas, urges that the changes, insofar as they affect medical and dental jobs, both demanding a longer and more complex training than other jobs, be reconsidered and introduced again only after extensive discussion and modification and a substantial period of transition.
This motion has been signed by a total of 123 MPs.
MP | Date | Constituency | Party | Type |
Austin Mitchell | 19/04/2006 | Great Grimsby | Labour | Proposed |
Peter Bottomley | 20/04/2006 | Worthing West | Conservative | Seconded |
Michael Penning | 20/04/2006 | Hemel Hempstead | Conservative | Seconded |
Alan Meale | 20/04/2006 | Mansfield | Labour | Seconded |
Linda Riordan | 20/04/2006 | Halifax | Labour | Seconded |
Angus MacNeil | 20/04/2006 | Na h-Eileanan an Iar | Scottish National Party | Seconded |
Alan Simpson | 20/04/2006 | Nottingham South | Labour | Signed |
Neil Gerrard | 20/04/2006 | Walthamstow | Labour | Signed |
Mohammad Sarwar | 24/04/2006 | Glasgow Central | Labour | Signed |
Lady Hermon | 24/04/2006 | North Down | UUP | Signed |
Paul Holmes | 24/04/2006 | Chesterfield | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Rob Marris | 24/04/2006 | Wolverhampton South West | Labour | Signed |
Harry Cohen | 24/04/2006 | Leyton and Wanstead | Labour | Signed |
David Drew | 24/04/2006 | Stroud | Labour | Signed |
Bill Etherington | 24/04/2006 | Sunderland North | Labour | Signed |
David Taylor | 24/04/2006 | North West Leicestershire | Labour | Signed |
Ben Wallace | 24/04/2006 | Lancaster and Wyre | Conservative | Signed |
Jim Devine | 24/04/2006 | Livingston | Labour | Signed |
Gregory Campbell | 25/04/2006 | East Londonderry | DUP | Signed |
Frank Cook | 25/04/2006 | Stockton North | Labour | Signed |
Jeremy Corbyn | 25/04/2006 | Islington North | Labour | Signed |
Gwyneth Dunwoody | 25/04/2006 | Crewe & Nantwich | Labour | Signed |
Ian Gibson | 25/04/2006 | Norwich North | Labour | Signed |
Mike Hancock | 25/04/2006 | Portsmouth South | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Mike Wood | 25/04/2006 | Batley and Spen | Labour | Signed |
Lyn Brown | 25/04/2006 | West Ham | Labour | Signed |
Lorely Burt | 25/04/2006 | Solihull | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Jo Swinson | 25/04/2006 | East Dunbartonshire | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Willie Rennie | 25/04/2006 | Dunfermline and West Fife | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Bob Russell | 26/04/2006 | Colchester | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
David Simpson | 26/04/2006 | Upper Bann | DUP | Signed |
Evan Harris | 26/04/2006 | Oxford West and Abingdon | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Charles Kennedy | 26/04/2006 | Ross, Skye and Lochaber | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Lembit | 26/04/2006 | Montgomeryshire | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Hywel Francis | 26/04/2006 | Aberavon | Labour | Signed |
Roger Godsiff | 26/04/2006 | Birmingham, Sparkbrook and Small Heath | Labour | Signed |
Rudi Vis | 26/04/2006 | Finchley and Golders Green | Labour | Signed |
Robert Wareing | 26/04/2006 | Liverpool, West Derby | Labour | Signed |
John Leech | 26/04/2006 | Manchester, Withington | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Stephen Williams | 26/04/2006 | Bristol West | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Peter Luff | 27/04/2006 | Mid Worcestershire | Conservative | Signed |
John Hemming | 27/04/2006 | Birmingham, Yardley | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Jennifer Willott | 27/04/2006 | Cardiff Central | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Marsha Singh | 02/05/2006 | Bradford West | Labour | Signed |
Dai Havard | 02/05/2006 | Merthyr Tydfil and Rhymney | Labour | Signed |
William McCrea | 02/05/2006 | South Antrim | DUP | Signed |
Ann McKechin | 02/05/2006 | Glasgow North | Labour | Signed |
Chris Mullin | 02/05/2006 | Sunderland South | Labour | Signed |
George Galloway | 02/05/2006 | Bethnal Green and Bow | Respect | Signed |
Robert Walter | 02/05/2006 | North Dorset | Conservative | Signed |
Steve Webb | 02/05/2006 | Northavon | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Phil Willis | 02/05/2006 | Harrogate and Knaresborough | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Sammy Wilson | 02/05/2006 | East Antrim | DUP | Signed |
Lynne Featherstone | 02/05/2006 | Hornsey and Wood Green | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Mark Hunter | 02/05/2006 | Cheadle | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Alan Reid | 03/05/2006 | Argyll and Bute | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Kelvin Hopkins | 03/05/2006 | Luton North | Labour | Signed |
Alasdair McDonnell | 03/05/2006 | Belfast South | Social Democratic and Labour Party | Signed |
Vincent Cable | 03/05/2006 | Twickenham | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Don Foster | 03/05/2006 | Bath | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Michael Moore | 04/05/2006 | Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Janet Dean | 04/05/2006 | Burton | Labour | Signed |
Stewart Hosie | 04/05/2006 | Dundee East | Scottish National Party | Signed |
Nick Harvey | 08/05/2006 | North Devon | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Stephen Dorrell | 08/05/2006 | Charnwood | Conservative | Signed |
Betty Williams | 08/05/2006 | Conwy | Labour | Signed |
Roger Williams | 08/05/2006 | Brecon and Radnorshire | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Greg Clark | 08/05/2006 | Tunbridge Wells | Conservative | Signed |
Edward Vaizey | 08/05/2006 | Wantage | Conservative | Signed |
Patrick Hall | 09/05/2006 | Bedford | Labour | Signed |
Robert Flello | 09/05/2006 | Stoke-on-Trent South | Labour | Signed |
Julia Goldsworthy | 09/05/2006 | Falmouth and Camborne | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Frank Field | 10/05/2006 | Birkenhead | Labour | Signed |
Edward Leigh | 11/05/2006 | Gainsborough | Conservative | Signed |
Ian Davidson | 11/05/2006 | Glasgow South West | Labour | Signed |
Jim McGovern | 11/05/2006 | Dundee West | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Rosindell | 12/05/2006 | Romford | Conservative | Signed |
Jim Cousins | 12/05/2006 | Newcastle upon Tyne Central | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Stunell | 12/05/2006 | Hazel Grove | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Richard Taylor | 12/05/2006 | Wyre Forest | Independent | Signed |
David Howarth | 12/05/2006 | Cambridge | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Clare Short | 15/05/2006 | Birmingham, Ladywood | Labour | Signed |
Edward Davey | 15/05/2006 | Kingston and Surbiton | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Louise Ellman | 15/05/2006 | Liverpool, Riverside | Labour | Signed |
Sandra Gidley | 15/05/2006 | Romsey | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Anthony D Wright | 15/05/2006 | Great Yarmouth | Labour | Signed |
Madeleine Moon | 15/05/2006 | Bridgend | Labour | Signed |
John Penrose | 15/05/2006 | Weston-Super-Mare | Conservative | Signed |
Andrew Love | 16/05/2006 | Edmonton | Labour | Signed |
George Mudie | 16/05/2006 | Leeds East | Labour | Signed |
Bill Olner | 16/05/2006 | Nuneaton | Labour | Signed |
Keith Vaz | 16/05/2006 | Leicester East | Labour | Signed |
Robert Smith | 18/05/2006 | West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Julie Morgan | 22/05/2006 | Cardiff North | Labour | Signed |
Paul Burstow | 22/05/2006 | Sutton and Cheam | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
David Clelland | 22/05/2006 | Tyne Bridge | Labour | Signed |
Derek Conway | 22/05/2006 | Old Bexley & Sidcup | Conservative | Signed |
Michael Jabez Foster | 22/05/2006 | Hastings and Rye | Labour | Signed |
Janet Anderson | 22/05/2006 | Rossendale and Darwen | Labour | Signed |
John Austin | 22/05/2006 | Erith and Thamesmead | Labour | Signed |
Paul Keetch | 23/05/2006 | Hereford | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Desmond Turner | 23/05/2006 | Brighton, Kemptown | Labour | Signed |
Philip Dunne | 23/05/2006 | Ludlow | Conservative | Signed |
Susan Kramer | 23/05/2006 | Richmond Park | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Charles Walker | 23/05/2006 | Broxbourne | Conservative | Signed |
Paul Rowen | 23/05/2006 | Rochdale | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Gordon Marsden | 25/05/2006 | Blackpool South | Labour | Signed |
Greg Mulholland | 25/05/2006 | Leeds North West | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Kate Hoey | 05/06/2006 | Vauxhall | Labour | Signed |
John Barrett | 05/06/2006 | Edinburgh West | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Matthew Taylor | 05/06/2006 | Truro and St Austell | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Sarah Teather | 05/06/2006 | Brent East | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Mark Oaten | 06/06/2006 | Winchester | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Martin Horwood | 12/06/2006 | Cheltenham | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Katy Clark | 19/06/2006 | North Ayrshire and Arran | Labour | Signed |
Adam Holloway | 19/06/2006 | Gravesham | Conservative | Signed |
Nicholas Clegg | 20/06/2006 | Sheffield, Hallam | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Pete Wishart | 10/07/2006 | Perth and North Perthshire | Scottish National Party | Signed |
Richard Younger-Ross | 18/07/2006 | Teignbridge | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Simon Hughes | 24/07/2006 | North Southwark and Bermondsey | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Malcolm Bruce | 24/07/2006 | Gordon | Liberal Democrat | Signed |
Gavin Strang | 24/07/2006 | Edinburgh East | Labour | Signed |
Jamie Reed | 09/10/2006 | Copeland | Labour | Signed |
Download raw data as
csv or
xml.