Parliament Website

Medical Diagnosis Guidelines

EDM number 552 in 2012-13, proposed by Jim Cunningham on 15/10/2012.
Categorised under the topics of Children and families, Health education and preventive medicine and Health services.

That this House recognises the tragic nature of the deaths of children through clinical misdiagnosis or malpractice; notes the study by the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine published in the British Medical Journal, Improving child health services in the UK: insights from Europe and their implications for the NHS reforms, reporting an inquiry in which `identifiable failure in the child's direct care' was found in 26 per cent of child deaths, and potentially avoidable factors in 43 per cent of deaths; further recognisesthat this is particularly regrettable in cases where the child's parent or carer was aware of the child's sickness but felt as though their concerns were not heeded by medical practitioners; appreciates the difficulty facing diagnosticians in distinguishing between common, minor complaints and rarer, life-threatening illnesses; believes that in the case of child diagnosis the instinct and observation of the child's main carer is frequently highly valuable in identifying symptoms; further notes the e-petition campaign for Bethany's Law to raise the profile of child misdiagnosis through insufficient consideration of the observations of a child's carer; and calls on the Government to ensure that medical diagnosis guidelines include particular emphasis on taking the observations of the child's main carer into account.

This motion has been signed by a total of 18 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Jim Cunningham15/10/2012Coventry SouthLabourProposed
Mark Durkan15/10/2012FoyleSocial Democratic and Labour PartySeconded
Peter Bottomley15/10/2012Worthing WestConservativeSeconded
Margaret Ritchie16/10/2012South DownSocial Democratic and Labour PartySeconded
Jim Shannon16/10/2012StrangfordDUPSeconded
Martin Caton16/10/2012GowerLabourSeconded
William McCrea17/10/2012South AntrimDUPSigned
Jim Dobbin17/10/2012Heywood and MiddletonLabourSigned
Mike Hancock17/10/2012Portsmouth SouthLiberal DemocratSigned
Lady Hermon18/10/2012North DownIndependentSigned
David Anderson18/10/2012BlaydonLabourSigned
Paul Murphy18/10/2012TorfaenLabourSigned
Paul Flynn19/10/2012Newport WestLabourSigned
David Crausby24/10/2012Bolton North EastLabourSigned
Mary Glindon24/10/2012North TynesideLabourSigned
George Howarth25/10/2012KnowsleyLabourSigned
Alan Meale25/10/2012MansfieldLabourSigned
Valerie Vaz30/10/2012Walsall SouthLabourSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.