Primacy Of The House Of Commons
EDM number 56 in 2002-03, proposed by David Clelland on 13/11/2002.
That this House believes that a reformed House of Lords should not be a duplicate of the House of Commons; further believes that the primacy of the elected House of Commons and its special responsibility of representing people must be maintained and that an elected second chamber, however constituted, would inevitably challenge that primacy and lead to bad government; and notes that it is entirely possible to create a representative and accountable second chamber without direct elections.
This motion has been signed by a total of 87 MPs, 3 of these signatures have been withdrawn.
MP | Date | Constituency | Party | Type |
David Clelland | 13/11/2002 | Tyne Bridge | Labour | Proposed |
Siobhain McDonagh | 13/11/2002 | Mitcham & Morden | Labour | Signed |
Colin Pickthall | 13/11/2002 | West Lancashire | Labour | Signed |
John McFall | 13/11/2002 | Dumbarton | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Rosemary McKenna | 13/11/2002 | Cumbernauld & Kilsyth | Labour | Signed |
Alan Meale | 13/11/2002 | Mansfield | Labour | Signed |
Bill Olner | 13/11/2002 | Nuneaton | Labour | Signed |
Russell Brown | 13/11/2002 | Dumfries | Labour | Signed |
Colin Burgon | 13/11/2002 | Elmet | Labour | Signed |
David Cairns | 13/11/2002 | Greenock & Inverclyde | Labour | Signed |
Ronnie Campbell | 13/11/2002 | Blyth Valley | Labour | Signed |
Tony Clarke | 13/11/2002 | Northampton South | Labour | Signed |
Frank Cook | 13/11/2002 | Stockton North | Labour | Signed |
Ross Cranston | 13/11/2002 | Dudley North | Labour | Signed |
John Cummings | 13/11/2002 | Easington | Labour | Signed |
Tam Dalyell | 13/11/2002 | Linlithgow | Labour | Signed |
Janet Dean | 13/11/2002 | Burton | Labour | Signed |
George Foulkes | 13/11/2002 | Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Mike Gapes | 13/11/2002 | Ilford South | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Irene Adams | 13/11/2002 | Paisley North | Labour | Signed |
David Amess | 13/11/2002 | Southend West | Conservative | Signed |
Anne Begg | 13/11/2002 | Aberdeen South | Labour | Signed |
David Stewart | 13/11/2002 | Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber | Labour | Signed |
Mark Tami | 13/11/2002 | Alyn & Deeside | Labour | Signed |
Teddy Taylor | 13/11/2002 | Rochford & Southend East | Conservative | Signed |
Dennis Turner | 13/11/2002 | Wolverhampton South East | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Desmond Turner | 13/11/2002 | Brighton, Kemptown | Labour | Signed |
Tom Watson | 13/11/2002 | West Bromwich East | Labour | Signed |
Ann Widdecombe | 13/11/2002 | Maidstone & The Weald | Conservative | Signed |
Betty Williams | 13/11/2002 | Conwy | Labour | Signed |
Nicholas Winterton | 13/11/2002 | Macclesfield | Conservative | Signed |
Jim Marshall | 13/11/2002 | Leicester South | Labour | Signed |
Peter Pike | 13/11/2002 | Burnley | Labour | Signed |
Syd Rapson | 13/11/2002 | Portsmouth North | Labour | Signed |
Geoffrey Robinson | 13/11/2002 | Coventry North West | Labour | Signed |
Marion Roe | 13/11/2002 | Broxbourne | Conservative | Signed |
Terry Rooney | 13/11/2002 | Bradford North | Labour | Signed |
Ernie Ross | 13/11/2002 | Dundee West | Labour | Signed |
Barry Sheerman | 13/11/2002 | Huddersfield | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Si | 13/11/2002 | Birmingham, Erdington | Labour | Signed |
Tom Harris | 13/11/2002 | Glasgow, Cathcart | Labour | Signed |
Stephen Hepburn | 13/11/2002 | Jarrow | Labour | Signed |
Kate Hoey | 13/11/2002 | Vauxhall | Labour | Signed |
Jimmy Hood | 13/11/2002 | Clydesdale | Labour | Signed |
Alan Howarth | 13/11/2002 | Newport East | Labour | Signed |
Kevin Hughes | 13/11/2002 | Doncaster North | Labour | Signed |
Brian Jenkins | 13/11/2002 | Tamworth | Labour | Signed |
Eric Illsley | 13/11/2002 | Barnsley Central | Labour | Signed |
Stephen McCabe | 13/11/2002 | Birmingham, Hall Green | Labour | Signed |
John Mann | 13/11/2002 | Bassetlaw | Labour | Signed |
Khalid Mahmood | 13/11/2002 | Birmingham, Perry Barr | Labour | Signed |
Calum MacDonald | 13/11/2002 | Na h-Eileanan an Iar | Labour | Signed |
Iain Luke | 13/11/2002 | Dundee East | Labour | Signed |
David Lepper | 13/11/2002 | Brighton, Pavilion | Labour Co-operative | Signed |
Jackie Lawrence | 13/11/2002 | Preseli Pembrokeshire | Labour | Signed |
Julie Kirkbride | 13/11/2002 | Bromsgrove | Conservative | Signed |
Piara S Khabra | 13/11/2002 | Ealing, Southall | Labour | Signed |
Gerald Kaufman | 13/11/2002 | Manchester, Gorton | Labour | Signed |
Eric Joyce | 13/11/2002 | Falkirk West | Labour | Signed |
Lynne Jones | 13/11/2002 | Birmingham, Selly Oak | Labour | Signed |
Kevan Jones | 13/11/2002 | North Durham | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Rosindell | 14/11/2002 | Romford | Conservative | Signed |
John Battle | 14/11/2002 | Leeds West | Labour | Signed |
Robert Wareing | 14/11/2002 | Liverpool, West Derby | Labour | Signed |
Bill Wiggin | 14/11/2002 | Leominster | Conservative | Signed |
Tom Cox | 18/11/2002 | Tooting | Labour | Signed |
Bob Spink | 19/11/2002 | Castle Point | Conservative | Signed |
Edward Garnier | 19/11/2002 | Harborough | Conservative | Signed |
Lindsay Hoyle | 19/11/2002 | Chorley | Labour | Signed |
Lady Hermon | 20/11/2002 | North Down | UUP | Signed |
George Howarth | 20/11/2002 | Knowsley North & Sefton East | Labour | Signed |
Tony Lloyd | 20/11/2002 | Manchester Central | Labour | Signed |
Andrew Miller | 20/11/2002 | Ellesmere Port & Neston | Labour | Signed |
Kali Mountford | 20/11/2002 | Colne Valley | Labour | Signed |
Jeff Ennis | 20/11/2002 | Barnsley East & Mexborough | Labour | Signed |
Roy Beggs | 20/11/2002 | East Antrim | UUP | Signed |
Ann Cryer | 25/11/2002 | Keighley | Labour | Signed |
Helen Jones | 25/11/2002 | Warrington North | Labour | Signed |
Bill Tynan | 26/11/2002 | Hamilton South | Labour | Signed |
John MacDougall | 27/11/2002 | Central Fife | Labour | Signed |
Tony Banks | 02/12/2002 | West Ham | Labour | Signed |
Martin O'Neill | 22/01/2003 | Ochil | Labour | Signed |
Roger Godsiff | 27/01/2003 | Birmingham, Sparkbrook & Small Heath | Labour | Signed |
Marsha Singh | 30/01/2003 | Bradford West | Labour | Signed |
Bridget Prentice | Unknown | | | Withdrawn |
Phil Hope | Unknown | | | Withdrawn |
Andrew George | Unknown | | | Withdrawn |
Download raw data as
csv or
xml.