Parliament Website

Audit Commission Report On Gp Fundholding

EDM number 927 in 1995-96, proposed by Hugh Bayley on 22/05/1996.

That this House welcomes the Audit Commission's report What The Doctor Ordered; notes that this is the first objective analysis of the effectiveness of general practitioner fundholding; expresses concern at the Audit Commission's conclusion that the administrative cost of fundholding is greater than savings it had achieved for improving patient care; expresses concern at the finding that few fundholders are using clinical audit and patient outcome information to target their health spending on treatments which work; recalls the Health Committee's concern about the lack of accountability of general practitioner fundholders and its recommendation that fundholders should be required to sign up to a local health strategy agreed with their health authority before gaining access to their budget; welcomes the Audit Commission's proposal for improving the accountability framework for fundholding and its recommendation that fundholders should take account of their health authority's local health priorities in their plans; recognises that general practitioner-led local commissioning, involving fundholding and non-fundholding general practitioners, is addressing these problems and appears to be delivering clinically effective and cost-effective treatment for patients; calls upon the Department of Health to fund independent research into the effectiveness of general practitioner commissioning; and calls upon the Leader of the House to schedule a debate on the Audit Commissioner's Report on general practitioner fundholding in Government time.

This motion has been signed by a total of 65 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Hugh Bayley22/05/1996York, City ofProposed
Gordon Prentice22/05/1996PendleSigned
Tony Worthington22/05/1996Clydebank & MilngavieSigned
Audrey Wise22/05/1996PrestonSigned
Tony Banks22/05/1996Newham North WestSigned
John Gunnell22/05/1996Leeds South and MorleySigned
Neil Gerrard22/05/1996WalthamstowSigned
Paul Flynn22/05/1996Newport WestSigned
Angela Eagle22/05/1996WallaseySigned
Ian Davidson22/05/1996Glasgow, GovanSigned
Ann Clwyd22/05/1996Cynon ValleySigned
Michael Clapham22/05/1996Barnsley West & PenistoneSigned
Judith Church22/05/1996DagenhamSigned
Malcolm Chisholm22/05/1996Edinburgh LeithSigned
Rhodri Morgan22/05/1996Cardiff WestSigned
Alice Mahon22/05/1996HalifaxSigned
Brian Sedgemore22/05/1996Hackney South & ShoreditchSigned
Barry Sheerman22/05/1996HuddersfieldSigned
Alan Simpson22/05/1996Nottingham SouthSigned
John Spellar22/05/1996Warley WestSigned
Peter Hardy22/05/1996WentworthSigned
Keith Hill22/05/1996StreathamSigned
Kevin Hughes22/05/1996Doncaster NorthSigned
David Jamieson22/05/1996Plymouth, DevonportSigned
Lynne Jones22/05/1996Birmingham, Selly OakSigned
Alan Keen22/05/1996Feltham & HestonSigned
Denis MacShane22/05/1996RotherhamSigned
Andrew Miller22/05/1996Ellesmere Port & NestonSigned
Ernie Ross04/06/1996Dundee WestSigned
John Heppell04/06/1996Nottingham EastSigned
Ken Livingstone04/06/1996Brent EastSigned
William McKelvey04/06/1996Kilmarnock & LoudounSigned
Dennis Skinner05/06/1996BolsoverSigned
Joan Walley05/06/1996Stoke-on-Trent NorthSigned
Gerry Steinberg05/06/1996Durham, City ofSigned
Harry Barnes05/06/1996North East DerbyshireSigned
Mike Hall05/06/1996Warrington SouthSigned
Norman Godman05/06/1996Greenock and Port GlasgowSigned
Kenneth Eastham05/06/1996Manchester, BlackleySigned
Jean Corston05/06/1996Bristol EastSigned
Keith Bradley05/06/1996Manchester, WithingtonSigned
Bill Michie05/06/1996Sheffield, HeeleySigned
Eddie Loyden05/06/1996Liverpool, GarstonSigned
John Evans05/06/1996St Helens NorthSigned
Anne Campbell06/06/1996CambridgeSigned
Maria Fyfe06/06/1996Glasgow, MaryhillSigned
Diane Abbott06/06/1996Hackney North & Stoke NewingtonSigned
Glenda Jackson07/06/1996Hampstead & HighgateSigned
Martin Redmond10/06/1996Don ValleySigned
Robert Wareing10/06/1996Liverpool, West DerbySigned
Richard Burden11/06/1996Birmingham, NorthfieldSigned
Jack Thompson11/06/1996WansbeckSigned
Eric Illsley11/06/1996Barnsley CentralSigned
Max Madden12/06/1996Bradford WestSigned
Mike Gapes12/06/1996Ilford SouthSigned
Win Griffiths12/06/1996BridgendSigned
Elfyn Llwyd18/06/1996Meirionnydd Nant ConwySigned
Bill Etherington18/06/1996Sunderland NorthSigned
Dafydd Wigley18/06/1996CaernarfonSigned
Rachel Squire19/06/1996Dunfermline WestSigned
Terry Davis19/06/1996Birmingham, Hodge HillSigned
Peter Pike24/06/1996BurnleySigned
Gerry Sutcliffe04/07/1996Bradford SouthSigned
Tommy Graham18/07/1996Renfrew West and InverclydeSigned
Tony Lloyd24/07/1996StretfordSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.