Parliament Website

Protection Of Compensation

EDM number 493 in 1995-96, proposed by Frank Cook on 22/02/1996.

That this House notes that rules governing recoupment of benefits received from compensation awarded as a result of an accident require such payment to be repaid when a personal injury claim is settled and that an amount equal to benefit paid in respect of injury or disease must be deducted from the compensation payment (whether or not it has been reduced because of contributory negligence), the deduction is made for what has been paid in benefits to the date of settlement, or for the first five years, whichever is sooner, and the compensator must pay the amount deducted to the Compensatory Recovery Unit of the DSS; notes that settlements less than ú2,500 are exempt from these rules but in such cases one of half of the benefits may be deducted from loss of earnings, that there are many cases where recovery is made from compensation awarded for pain and suffering, and that claimants are often pressed by insurance companies to accept ú2,500, an amount well below the value of their claim, rather than have it swallowed entirely by the repayment rules, and that the only ones to benefit from this are insurance houses who save many thousands of pounds in this way and neither injured party nor the Revenue gain anything; and urges Her Majesty's Government to introuce legislation so that no recoupment of benefits be made from compensation for pain and suffering or out of pocket expenses incurred as a result of an accident, account be taken of reduction for contributory negligence and the first ú2,500 of all claims be exempt from the recoupment provisions.

This motion has been signed by a total of 44 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Frank Cook22/02/1996Stockton NorthProposed
Ken Livingstone26/02/1996Brent EastSigned
Paddy Tipping26/02/1996SherwoodSigned
Norman Godman26/02/1996Greenock and Port GlasgowSigned
Ernie Ross27/02/1996Dundee WestSigned
Robert Wareing27/02/1996Liverpool, West DerbySigned
Harry Barnes27/02/1996North East DerbyshireSigned
Lawrence Cunliffe27/02/1996LeighSigned
Michael Connarty27/02/1996Falkirk EastSigned
William McKelvey27/02/1996Kilmarnock & LoudounSigned
John McAllion27/02/1996Dundee EastSigned
Alice Mahon27/02/1996HalifaxSigned
Elfyn Llwyd27/02/1996Meirionnydd Nant ConwySigned
Lynne Jones27/02/1996Birmingham, Selly OakSigned
Eric Illsley27/02/1996Barnsley CentralSigned
Peter Hardy27/02/1996WentworthSigned
Dennis Skinner27/02/1996BolsoverSigned
Alan Simpson27/02/1996Nottingham SouthSigned
Mike Hall28/02/1996Warrington SouthSigned
Paul Flynn28/02/1996Newport WestSigned
Terry Davis28/02/1996Birmingham, Hodge HillSigned
Edward O'Hara28/02/1996Knowsley SouthSigned
Alan Meale28/02/1996MansfieldSigned
Eddie Loyden28/02/1996Liverpool, GarstonSigned
Eric Clarke28/02/1996MidlothianSigned
Helen Jackson29/02/1996Sheffield, HillsboroughSigned
Audrey Wise29/02/1996PrestonSigned
Martyn Jones05/03/1996Clwyd South WestSigned
Maria Fyfe05/03/1996Glasgow, MaryhillSigned
Gerry Steinberg05/03/1996Durham, City ofSigned
Clive Betts06/03/1996Sheffield, AttercliffeSigned
Jack Thompson06/03/1996WansbeckSigned
Jean Corston06/03/1996Bristol EastSigned
Ian McCartney06/03/1996MakerfieldSigned
Bill Etherington07/03/1996Sunderland NorthSigned
Terry Lewis11/03/1996WorsleySigned
Ann Clwyd11/03/1996Cynon ValleySigned
Tessa Jowell12/03/1996DulwichSigned
David Marshall12/03/1996Glasgow, ShettlestonSigned
Joyce Quin18/03/1996Gateshead EastSigned
Tommy Graham19/03/1996Renfrew West and InverclydeSigned
Win Griffiths21/03/1996BridgendSigned
John Gunnell27/03/1996Leeds South and MorleySigned
Joan Ruddock01/04/1996Lewisham, DeptfordSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.