Parliament Website

Badgers And Tuberculosis In Cattle

EDM number 504 in 1991-92, proposed by Tony Banks on 20/01/1992.

That this House notes that there is no evidence that the Ministry of Agriculture's badger culling programme, at an annual cost to tax payers approaching ú500,000, is having any effect on the incidence of tuberculosis in cattle; further notes that there is scant scientific evidence for the transmission of tuberculosis from badgers to cattle and that there is probably more evidence for the transmission of tuberculosis from cattle to badgers; believes that the additional cost to tax payers of compensating farmers fully for infected cattle, at about ú400,000 in a bad year and less than ú300.000 in a typical year, would be less than the cost of continuing the badger culling programme; and calls on this Government to impose an immediate moratorium on badger culling pending a review of the situation and to reconsider the level of compensation paid to farmers for cattle infected with tuberculosis.

This motion has been signed by a total of 89 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Tony Banks20/01/1992Newham North WestProposed
Roy Hughes20/01/1992Newport EastSeconded
Dawn Primarolo20/01/1992Bristol SouthSeconded
Alan Meale20/01/1992MansfieldSeconded
Peter Hardy20/01/1992WentworthSeconded
Elliot Morley20/01/1992Glanford and ScunthorpeSeconded
Keith Bradley20/01/1992Manchester, WithingtonSigned
Ronnie Campbell20/01/1992Blyth ValleySigned
Harry Cohen20/01/1992LeytonSigned
Alistair Darling20/01/1992Edinburgh CentralSigned
Ron Davies20/01/1992CaerphillySigned
Frank Field20/01/1992BirkenheadSigned
Paul Flynn20/01/1992Newport WestSigned
John Fraser20/01/1992NorwoodSigned
George Galloway20/01/1992Glasgow HillheadSigned
Llin Golding20/01/1992Newcastle-under-LymeSigned
Graham Allen20/01/1992Nottingham NorthSigned
Win Griffiths20/01/1992BridgendSigned
Peter Hain20/01/1992NeathSigned
Harry Barnes20/01/1992North East DerbyshireSigned
John Battle20/01/1992Leeds WestSigned
Stuart Bell20/01/1992MiddlesbroughSigned
Tony Benn20/01/1992ChesterfieldSigned
Gerry Bermingham20/01/1992St Helens SouthSigned
Paul Boateng20/01/1992Brent SouthSigned
Jack Thompson20/01/1992WansbeckSigned
Dennis Turner20/01/1992Wolverhampton South EastSigned
Mike Watson20/01/1992Glasgow CentralSigned
Alan Williams20/01/1992Swansea WestSigned
Alan Wynne Williams20/01/1992CarmarthenSigned
Norman Hogg20/01/1992Cumbernauld & KilsythSigned
Roland Boyes20/01/1992Houghton and WashingtonSigned
Robert Parry20/01/1992Liverpool, RiversideSigned
Jeff Rooker20/01/1992Birmingham, Perry BarrSigned
Terry Rooney20/01/1992Bradford NorthSigned
Ernie Ross20/01/1992Dundee WestSigned
Ted Rowlands20/01/1992Merthyr Tydfil & RhymneySigned
Dennis Skinner20/01/1992BolsoverSigned
Andrew Smith20/01/1992Oxford EastSigned
Nigel Spearing20/01/1992Newham SouthSigned
David Hinchliffe20/01/1992WakefieldSigned
Eric Illsley20/01/1992Barnsley CentralSigned
William McKelvey20/01/1992Kilmarnock & LoudounSigned
Edward O'Hara20/01/1992Knowsley SouthSigned
Mo Mowlam20/01/1992RedcarSigned
Lewis Moonie20/01/1992KirkcaldySigned
John McWilliam20/01/1992BlaydonSigned
Greville Janner20/01/1992Leicester WestSigned
John McAllion20/01/1992Dundee EastSigned
Eric Martlew20/01/1992CarlisleSigned
Calum MacDonald20/01/1992Na h-Eileanan an IarSigned
Eddie Loyden20/01/1992Liverpool, GarstonSigned
Terry Lewis20/01/1992WorsleySigned
David Lambie20/01/1992Cunninghame SouthSigned
Lawrence Cunliffe21/01/1992LeighSigned
Gerry Steinberg21/01/1992Durham, City ofSigned
Andrew Faulds21/01/1992Warley EastSigned
John Evans21/01/1992St Helens NorthSigned
Terry Davis21/01/1992Birmingham, Hodge HillSigned
Bill Michie21/01/1992Sheffield, HeeleySigned
Ian McCartney21/01/1992MakerfieldSigned
Ashok Kumar21/01/1992LangbaurghSigned
Terry Patchett21/01/1992Barnsley EastSigned
Frank Cook21/01/1992Stockton NorthSigned
Dave Nellist22/01/1992Coventry South EastSigned
Peter Bottomley22/01/1992ElthamSigned
Maria Fyfe22/01/1992Glasgow, MaryhillSigned
Huw Edwards22/01/1992MonmouthSigned
Tom Cox22/01/1992TootingSigned
Alun Michael22/01/1992Cardiff South & PenarthSigned
Alice Mahon22/01/1992HalifaxSigned
Chris Smith22/01/1992Islington South & FinsburySigned
Martin Redmond22/01/1992Don ValleySigned
John Smith23/01/1992Vale of GlamorganSigned
Andrew Bowden23/01/1992Brighton, KemptownSigned
Tommy Graham23/01/1992Renfrew West and InverclydeSigned
Norman Godman23/01/1992Greenock and Port GlasgowSigned
John Cummings23/01/1992EasingtonSigned
Ken Livingstone23/01/1992Brent EastSigned
Joan Lestor23/01/1992EcclesSigned
Kim Howells23/01/1992PontypriddSigned
Joyce Quin23/01/1992Gateshead EastSigned
Frank Doran24/01/1992Aberdeen SouthSigned
Gareth Wardell27/01/1992GowerSigned
Peter Pike28/01/1992BurnleySigned
Tony Lloyd28/01/1992StretfordSigned
Denzil Davies28/01/1992LlanelliSigned
Ian Grist28/01/1992Cardiff CentralSigned
Martyn Jones03/02/1992Clwyd South WestSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.