Parliament Website

Conduct Of The Minister Of Agriculture With Regard To Spongiform Encephalopathy And Cats

EDM number 983 in 1989-90, proposed by Harry Cohen on 14/05/1990.

That this House notes the exchange in the committee on the Food Safety Bill on 29th March, between the honourable Member for Leyton and the Agriculture Minister, the honourable Member for Penrith and the Border, in which the former said, at column 123, 'I feed my cats every day; no doubt the cat food contains a lot of offal and much of that might well be infected.' and called for a straight answer from the Minister on whether that was so; and that the Minister replied, at column 125, 'I do not want to get into the position where I as a politician go into a crazy panic over pet food, when all the evidence is against there being any risk whatever of the disease jumping species to cats and dogs. I could ban the pet food for no good reason and the scientists could a year later say I was wrong' and stated that policy on a serious issue such as bovine spongiform encephalopathy should not be based on the love of the honourable Member for Leyton for his cat; notes the reports of 10th May of the cat in Bristol with the species equivalent of bovine spongiform encephalopathy and calls for immediate action to ban any potential infected offal or meat from pet food or, failing that, that the Minister considers his position and resigns.

This motion has been signed by a total of 28 MPs.

MPDateConstituencyPartyType
Harry Cohen14/05/1990LeytonProposed
Ernie Ross15/05/1990Dundee WestSigned
John McAllion15/05/1990Dundee EastSigned
William McKelvey15/05/1990Kilmarnock & LoudounSigned
Alan Meale15/05/1990MansfieldSigned
Terry Davis15/05/1990Birmingham, Hodge HillSigned
James Wray15/05/1990Glasgow ProvanSigned
Ann Taylor16/05/1990DewsburySigned
Alan Wynne Williams16/05/1990CarmarthenSigned
Gerry Steinberg16/05/1990Durham, City ofSigned
John Evans16/05/1990St Helens NorthSigned
Roland Boyes16/05/1990Houghton and WashingtonSigned
Bill Michie16/05/1990Sheffield, HeeleySigned
Sylvia Heal16/05/1990Staffordshire MidSigned
Dennis Skinner16/05/1990BolsoverSigned
Lawrence Cunliffe16/05/1990LeighSigned
Bob Cryer17/05/1990Bradford SouthSigned
Jimmy Dunnachie21/05/1990Glasgow, PollokSigned
Keith Vaz21/05/1990Leicester EastSigned
Peter Hardy21/05/1990WentworthSigned
Joyce Quin21/05/1990Gateshead EastSigned
Jack Thompson24/05/1990WansbeckSigned
Martyn Jones05/06/1990Clwyd South WestSigned
Terry Patchett07/06/1990Barnsley EastSigned
Eric Illsley07/06/1990Barnsley CentralSigned
Eddie Loyden07/06/1990Liverpool, GarstonSigned
Ian McCartney07/06/1990MakerfieldSigned
Andrew Faulds12/06/1990Warley EastSigned

Download raw data as csv or xml.